North Pole Cookie Shop is OPEN
your favorite cape batter cookies ready to ship to the ones you love!
pre-order below
Event dates & Availability
Come See Us:
Saturday 12/6 @ Plymouth Holiday Market, Memorial Hall 11am-5pm
Sunday 12/7 @ Pinehills Jingle All the Way Holiday Market, Plymouth 11am-4pm
Sunday 12/14 @ Gifted Holiday Market, Fairmont Copley Plaza Hotel 11am-4pm
We are currently booked until
December 15th, 2025
for all custom orders and events!
Holiday Pre-Orders are now OPEN!
please note: we are a licensed residential bakery that provides pick ups and delivery only. No walk ins/dine in service, thank you
please note: we are a licensed residential bakery that provides pick ups and delivery only. No walk ins/dine in service, thank you
*** Pick Up & Event dates are booked on a first come first serve basis with order payment and finalization made in advance. We do not hold dates, so please be sure to pay by the order deadline sent on your final order invoice to secure your booking. It is never too early to book and we highly recommend submitting custom requests with at least a six week lead time of your event date. If you are in need for a more urgent order, please call us directly at 646. 285. 7892. and we will do our best to accommodate your request provided there is availability. ***
Be sure to follow us on facebook & instagram
Have a custom request?
All custom cakes are separate from our signature collection and start at $150.00. For our Signature Cakes & Sweet Treats, please visit our Menu page to submit a separate request.
Custom Request Order Form
see what our customers have to say…
-
![White birthday cake with floral decorations and koi fish designs, topped with a "Happy Birthday" sign, on a wooden cake stand in Plymouth MA.]()
I would go back here again in a heartbeat! Natasha was so friendly and attentive to my request for a custom coconut cake for my daughter’s 40th birthday. The cake was so light, but also rich and moist! Both the vanilla pastry filling and buttercream frosting were the perfect flavor contrast. DELICIOUS!!! Natasha created an ivory and gold mermaid/shell design – GORGEOUS - and my daughter LOVED IT!!!
Emily Kronenberger
-
![Decorated cookies shaped like cowboy boots, planes, onesies, and rainbows on a dark surface, each individually wrapped in plastic in Plymouth MA.]()
I live in Texas, but my friend lives in Plymouth. When her Texas friends wanted to throw a virtual baby shower for her, I reached out to Natasha and discussed the idea of her doing the cookies and delivering them in time for the Zoom event. She was amazing! She even went out to get a Texas cookie cutter and made the perfect cookie for my Texas-transplant friend's baby! The communication was spot on and I am so glad we went with Cape Batter Bakeshop for the shower!
kerri harris
-
![Cupcakes with blue and white frosting, adorned with crescent moon and star shapes, placed in a box in Plymouth MA.]()
I cannot recommend Cape Batter more! Natasha was such a pleasure to work with and really helped me come up with a vision for the most adorable cupcakes for a baby shower. She provided amazing suggestions for both design and flavor. The cupcakes themselves were so beautifully decorated and tasted even better! I will absolutely be a returning customer!
Rachel Quimby
-
![Two-tier semi-naked wedding cake with white frosting adorned with cream and blush roses, dark flowers, and green eucalyptus leaves, placed on a white cake stand at Cape Batter in Plymouth MA.]()
Cape Batter made the cake for my wedding and it was STUNNING! Not only did it look amazing it also tasted fantastic. The owner was friendly and easy to work with. Highly recommend Cape Batter :)
jordan shea
-
![]()
Natasha was great to work with and very responsive to questions. She made beautiful cupcakes and cake pops that matched the theme of my sisters baby shower perfectly. Everyone raved about how beautiful and delicious the treats were. We will definitely be using Cape Batter again!
lindsey donovan
-
![A wooden barrel end table displaying a variety of items including decorative cookies, a toy truck, a wooden box with mountain engravings, greenery sprigs, and a pine cone. The table is set against a rustic background with a stone texture on one side.]()
My mom ordered cookies for my bridal shower this past weekend and they came out awesome! The cookies looked beautiful and were delicious! She said Natasha was a pleasure to work with and very talented. She highly recommends cape batter to anyone!
Meghan mcgonagle
-
![Halloween-themed cake with a pink frosting, colorful sprinkles, and a fondant cauldron design, topped with a sign featuring three silhouettes and the phrase 'Winnie... I smell a child.']()
Ordered a cake and cupcakes with a "Hocus Pocus" theme for a gender reveal party! Everyone loved it. The presentation was great and it was all delicious. My favorite part was the light frosting! Highly recommend!
marua rogers
-
![Number 70 cake with decorations, including flowers, pastel seashells, and butterflies. Gold "Happy Birthday" topperin Plymouth MA.]()
I highly recommend Cape Batter! I ordered a specialty cake for my mother’s birthday and she absolutely loved it. Natasha talked through the design with me and offered suggestions that turned out wonderfully, like the number shape. The cake was delicious and even included macarons on top! I could not be happier with my experience, thanks Cape Batter :)
sierra carrasco
-
![Red, white, and blue popsicles and macarons with sprinkles]()
So delicious! The deserts truly taste as good as they look! Perfect for any occasion, my friends and family all loved the macaroons and cake pops. Can’t wait to go back for more!!
Hailey Brunner
-
![A two-tiered cake with pastel decorations featuring rabbits, stars, and a crescent moon topper, displayed on a wooden slab. The cake is surrounded by other treats on a tablecloth in Plymouth MA.]()
Natasha is so talented!! This cake was almost too beautiful to cut, but luckily it was worth every bite - so delicious! Natasha was so helpful and had great communication through every step of the ordering process. I highly recommend her!
leah pow
